23 Nov 2023
by Nick Ismail

Reduce cyber risk and complexity with security vendor consolidation

Guest blog by Nicholas Ismail, Global Head of Brand Journalism at HCLTech

The cybersecurity landscape is complex.

Initially, organizations approached cyber with a scattergun approach, buying and deploying a variety of best-of-breed solutions, which were implemented by numerous vendors.  Most deployments ended up as either shelfware or as incomplete deployments. It was similar to the Wild West.

Today, the landscape has evolved. Enterprises are moving towards a cloud first approach, with cloud-native applications, built to run in cloud environments. This has led to a significant paradigm shift.

By 2025, Gartner predicts that 70% of organizations will consolidate the number of vendors securing the lifecycle of cloud-native applications to a maximum of three vendors.

This trend isn’t limited to the cloud and in 2022, the research analyst firm found that 75% of organizations pursued security vendor consolidation, up from 29% in 2020. Improving cyber risk posture was identified as the number one factor by 65% in this stark shift in strategy.

On top of this, Prashant Mascarenhas, Vice President - Cybersecurity & GRC Services at HCLTech, speaking at RSA conference, says that the talent shortage is a key reason for security vendor consolidation.

“In the cybersecurity industry, cyber skills are at a premium. With multiple vendors in an enterprise environment, there are risks around a lack of skills, the lack of the right kind of talent and the potential loss of knowledge. When the talent moves, there is implicit knowledge that moves along with the talent, which creates risks for the enterprise.”

The talent challenge

A multi-vendor environment typically blends into a situation where organizations either have a contingent workforce who are brought in to do point-in-time projects or multiple vendors sourcing talent from different places. This creates several risks around loss of knowledge and a lack of service continuity and quality.

“If you lose a resource who was managing critical infrastructure then that environment is now not supported anymore,” says Mascarenhas.

He adds: “The inevitable churn of talent also creates a problem. There's always a risk of malicious behavior creeping in. The insider threat, intentional or not, has always been cited as a very large risk to the enterprise. If there isn’t the right set of controls for the talent that’s coming in, the insider risk grows.”

In addition, multiple different vendors in the environment will have overlapping responsibilities. This could impact an enterprises’ security posture, leading to gaps in enterprise resiliency and potential security incidents.

Seamlessly consolidating vendors

Leading a vendor consolidation requires a collaborative effort between cybersecurity line leaders and IT executives, who have vendor management experience.

According to Mascarenhas, the first step to seamlessly consolidating security vendors is to view the strategy from a long-term business case standpoint.

Any vendor consolidation strategy must span over not just risk mitigation, but cost, service continuity and service improvement.

The second element to consider is talent. “During a vendor consolidation, there is the potential to lose some good talent. It’s important that talent gets handled in the right manner so they can transfer the tribal knowledge and contextual understanding they’ve gained on the environment,” he says.

Another aspect in any consolidation exercise is the importance of change management.

“It’s something that is often overlooked, but it’s important as there are multiple dimensions of organizational change management that need to be handled through the entire consolidation exercise, starting right at the inception planning stage,” adds Mascarenhas.

Finding the right partner who will invest in the long-term success of the relationship is the final and crucial factor for a seamless vendor consolidation.

When considering a partner, Mascarenhas advises organizations look at their approach to talent creation and scaling perspective, what levers they can apply from a human effort production perspective with technologies like automation and how they can invest in proactively cannibalizing services revenue, while still improving the outcomes that are being delivered.

"On this journey, organizations will need a true end-to-end partner who's aligned to the business and security outcomes that the enterprise wants to drive, while investing in building the right skill pool to support the medium to long-term initiatives,” he says.

You can read the original blog here

Cyber Security Programme

The Cyber Security Programme provides a channel for our industry to engage with commercial and government partners to support growth in this vital sector, which underpins and enables all organisations. The programme brings together industry and government to overcome the joint challenges the sector faces and to pursue key opportunities to ensure the UK remains a leading cyber nation, including on issues such as the developing threat, bridging the skills gap and secure-by-design.

Learn more

Join techUK's Cyber Security SME Forum

Our new group will keep techUK members updated on the latest news and views from across the Cyber security landscape. The group will also spotlight events and engagement opportunities for members to get involved in.

Join here

Cyber Security updates

Sign-up to get the latest updates and opportunities from our Cyber Security programme.





Nick Ismail

Nick Ismail

Global Head of Brand, HCLTech

Nick Ismail is the Global Head of Brand Journalism at HCLTech. He is responsible for delivering the editorial and content strategy. He previously spent 6 years leading the content for Information Age, a B2B technology publication headquartered in London.