Skip to content

Britain's mobile network needs a right to build

18 November 20262 min read
Guest Insights
Abstract digital wave pattern of blue and red data points illustrating digital connectivity

Britain's mobile network now ranks 53rd in the world – the worst in the G7 and behind every EU nation except Cyprus. In a developed country this isn't acceptable. That's why we set up the campaign group Buffering Britain. This week, with the Centre for British Progress, we've published the blueprint to get Britain connected again. 

The biggest problem we've found is a shortage of capacity. Too few cells are being shared between too many people. Your phone can show full bars at a busy station or a packed gig, but you still won't be able to load a thing. More than 50,000 tests through our app suggest up to two in five mobile users can’t play video clips on websites or social media. By comparing mobile speeds at busy and quiet times of day, we estimate that congestion costs consumers between £490 and £785 million a year. 

If we don't do something, then the problem is likely to get worse. Between 2018 and 2025 mobile traffic rose by almost 500%. While direct-to-cell satellites – like Starlink – can help with not-spots, they're not yet able to offer the kind of capacity needed in densely populated areas. We need more antennas closer to users. 

The mobile network operators want to build them, but time and again we've found councils stopping them from doing so. Most masts in England have permitted development rights, but new ground-based masts still go through prior approval, which lets councils veto them on grounds of siting and appearance. 

Over five years, Richmond upon Thames refused 96% of these applications and Islington 74%. In Cardiff and Glasgow it's even worse: they refused every single mast application over the same time period. Upgrades to existing masts face similar planning hurdles. VodafoneThree says that 96% of its planned upgrades are on existing sites and that more than half will need planning permission of some kind. 

We welcome the government's new National Planning Policy Framework, which tells local authorities to give "substantial weight" to improvements in network capacity. techUK has rightly argued for the planning system to recognise telecoms as essential infrastructure and the public benefit of better connectivity, and this was a welcome step in that direction.  

But we need to go further Part 16 of the General Permitted Development Order – which sets out the prior approval process – is unchanged, so councils determined to block masts can still do so on visual grounds. 

To solve this problem, we propose a national right to build mobile infrastructure. Masts and equipment meeting published conditions – set by national government – on size, siting, and design would move from prior approval to prior notification. An operator would then be able to tell the council what it planned to build and could start work 28 days later. Councils would only be able to object if the proposal broke one or more of the national conditions. The Planning Inspectorate would then rule on those conditions alone and an objection wouldn't be able to stop the clock. 

For those investing in the network, this would create certainty. Because the conditions would be published ahead of time, operators could design sites around them and know that their work would be able to go ahead before investing time and money. We propose extending the same right to independent infrastructure providers, so networks could commission masts from whichever company was best placed to build them. 

We also want the rules to reward sharing, as this reduces the number of masts needed overall. Right now, upgrades to smaller masts that enable sharing are still gummed up by the planning system. And small cells built for all networks face the same limits as those built for a single network. Our proposals would see fixed national limits on the finished installation with upgrades able to increase the size of an existing mast to that allowed for a new one. We also propose allowing small cells 50 litres of space for each network they carry. 

Appearance is very often the reason why councils – and locals – object to masts. To solve this problem, we're advocating for a national pattern book of approved designs, which would form part of the national conditions mentioned earlier. A mast built to an approved design in its specified setting would qualify for the right to build. The first edition should come from an open competition, inspired by the way the Post Office chose Giles Gilbert Scott's K2 telephone kiosk in the 1920s. 

We commissioned the think tank Create Streets to run a preliminary survey on this. In it, 54% of respondents preferred a redesigned installation compared to 27% who preferred the conventional alternative. Manufacturers would gain a market for approved designs and operators would then have a reason to pay for them. 

We focus on planning first because it is directly within the government's control and can be easily changed. But we also propose a duty on councils, NHS trusts, and government departments to answer requests to host mobile equipment within a fixed timetable. And building owners who pay for shared indoor systems should be able to access every network if they're willing to pay. 

The government should start by amending Part 16, which would let the industry invest money it is already willing to spend on sites where customers are in dire need of better service. We hope that all those who care about this issue will help us to amplify the case and demand better of the government. Poor connectivity is a choice – it's time to make a different one.