Emma Fryer Musing on Beetles

  • techUK techUK
    Friday22Mar 2019

    Lot9 requirements are causing more problems. Can we learn anything from Darwin, Adam Smith, or beetles?

Lot9 is part of the EU’s EcoDesign Directive, aimed at reducing energy use in products at the design stage.  Products are grouped by type, or “Lots” for legislative attention.  Lot9 refers to computer servers and the regulatory proposals have been very contentious, primarily about the way we measure server efficiency and the inclusion of idle running limits.  Other problems have emerged - the wording of the legislation includes errors and enforcement proposals do not accommodate the diversity of server configurations.   The devil is truly in the detail here but the Lot9 experience does place a large question mark over the policy process itself and the way that over-ambitious legislation, too prescriptively applied, can put policy instruments, designed with the best intentions, at odds with basic laws of nature – and economics.   We aren’t pretending to solve this problem here, but it’s worth standing back and asking this kind of question from time to time. 

  • Emma Fryer

    Emma Fryer

    T 01609 772 137
configuration beetles 03 (docx)

Share this


One month to go until #SmarterStateUK 2019. Join us on 18 September, along with digital leaders from across the pub… https://t.co/VpqmzqeVfK
Join us on 06 November in #Manchester for #Supercharging the Digital Economy 2019. We'll be discussing how digital… https://t.co/kMvV06oX7E
Make sure you get your vote in before the deadline this Friday! #womenintech #CWwit50 https://t.co/1eaIpNRE1I
Neil Ross (@neil13r), Policy Manager at techUK, writes on the impact of Brexit on data flows and the importance of… https://t.co/9qweZGGEQK
Calling all #healthtech suppliers: @NHSX wants to bring all guidance on information governance together in one pl… https://t.co/FcD9QAKYnB
Just over 1 month to go until #techUKSmarterState 2019. Book your ticket now and join 200+ digital leaders from acr… https://t.co/Zp3IL6n0Bv
Become a Member

Become a techUK Member

By becoming a techUK member we will help you grow through:

Click here to learn more...